Ancestry Vs 23andme Reddit

ancestry vs 23andme Reddit

If you're interested in learning more about your genetic background and ancestry, you may have come across the popular DNA testing services Ancestry and 23andMe. Both of these companies offer genetic testing kits that can provide you with valuable insights into your family history and health. However, choosing between the two can be a difficult decision. In this article, we will explore the differences between Ancestry and 23andMe and how Reddit users compare the two.

Ancestry DNA is primarily focused on genealogy and family history. They provide users with detailed ethnicity estimates, allowing you to discover your ancestral origins from over 1,000 regions around the world. Ancestry also has a robust genealogical database, which can help you connect with relatives you may not have known about. Many Reddit users appreciate Ancestry's extensive collection of historical records, which can provide valuable insights into your family's past.

On the other hand, 23andMe offers a more comprehensive testing experience. In addition to providing ethnicity estimates, they also provide health reports that can inform you about potential genetic health risks, carrier status for certain conditions, and even traits you may have inherited. This additional health information can be particularly useful for those interested in learning more about their genetic predispositions. Reddit users often mention the value they find in 23andMe's health reports and the ability to connect with others who share similar genetic traits or conditions.

When it comes to DNA testing, accuracy and reliability are crucial factors to consider. Both Ancestry and 23andMe have undergone rigorous testing and have been shown to provide accurate results. However, it's important to remember that DNA testing is not 100% perfect, and there is always a margin of error. Reddit users have reported varying experiences with both services, with some finding the results to be incredibly accurate and others experiencing discrepancies.

Cost is another important consideration when choosing between Ancestry and 23andMe. Ancestry DNA offers their testing kit at a slightly lower price point compared to 23andMe. However, it's important to keep in mind that Ancestry requires a subscription to access their genealogical database, which can add to the overall cost. 23andMe, on the other hand, offers a one-time fee for their testing kit and access to all their features. Reddit users often debate the value of each service, with some finding the additional features of 23andMe to be worth the extra cost.

Privacy and data security are important considerations when it comes to DNA testing. Both Ancestry and 23andMe have privacy policies in place to protect your data, but it's essential to review these policies before making a decision. Reddit users often discuss the potential risks and benefits of sharing their genetic information with these companies.

Customer support is another aspect that Reddit users often consider when comparing Ancestry and 23andMe. Both companies offer customer support options, but the quality and responsiveness can vary. Some users have reported positive experiences with both companies, while others have encountered difficulties in reaching out for assistance.

How long does it take to get the results?

The turnaround time for both Ancestry and 23andMe can vary, but it usually takes around 6-8 weeks to receive your results.

Can I download and share my DNA data?

Yes, both Ancestry and 23andMe allow you to download and share your DNA data if you wish to do so.

Can I connect with relatives through the service?

Yes, both Ancestry and 23andMe allow you to connect with relatives and potential DNA matches.

Will my DNA information be used for research purposes?

Ancestry and 23andMe both offer the option to participate in research studies, but it is voluntary, and you can choose whether or not to participate.

Can the tests determine specific tribes or ethnic groups?

While the tests can provide broad ethnicity estimates, they may not be able to pinpoint specific tribes or ethnic groups with high accuracy.

Are the tests suitable for children?

Ancestry and 23andMe typically require individuals to be at least 18 years old to take the test, but they may have options for minors with parental consent.

Can the tests determine paternity or maternity?

Both Ancestry and 23andMe can provide information about potential relatives, but they are not designed specifically for paternity or maternity testing.

Can I use the results for legal purposes?

The results from Ancestry and 23andMe are not typically admissible in a court of law.


- Ancestry offers a vast collection of historical records for genealogical research.

- 23andMe provides detailed health reports and information about potential genetic risks.

- Both services offer the ability to connect with relatives and potential DNA matches.


- Before purchasing a DNA test, consider what specific information you are looking to gain from the results.

- Read reviews and experiences from other users to get a better understanding of each service's strengths and weaknesses.

- Take advantage of the genealogical and historical resources available through Ancestry and the health reports provided by 23andMe.


When it comes to choosing between Ancestry and 23andMe, it ultimately depends on your individual preferences and what you hope to gain from the testing experience. Ancestry is a great option for those interested in genealogical research and connecting with relatives, while 23andMe offers additional health-related insights. Reddit users have varying opinions on which service is better, so it's important to carefully consider your own goals and priorities before making a decision.